When it comes to your career progression, figuring out how to choose the right recruitment agency is a hugely important and often overlooked part of the journey. From providing access to a network of industry experts, advising on career development or contract issues, or simply acting as a sounding board to help formulate your approach, recruiters will give you vital support when you need it most.

But with so many choices in the market, how do you choose the right recruitment agency for your needs? Here are our five top tips to help you make the best decision for your next job search.

How to Choose the Right Recruitment Agency: 5 Top Tips

1. Assess Your Needs Before Approaching a Recruitment Agency

Before you contact a recruitment agency, you need to be aware of your own needs, the kind of work you are looking for, and the challenges you feel you need a little help to overcome. This small bit of homework involves more than identifying an ideal job title; it requires a proper review of your professional goals. Start by thinking about the type of roles that interest you. Are you looking for a position that challenges your technical abilities or one that offers scope for creative expression? Perhaps a leadership role that leverages your people management skills is what you really want.

Equally important is understanding the kind of organisational culture that clicks with you. Do you love a dynamic, fast-paced environment, or do you prefer a steady, more structured setting? Consider also the size of the organisation. Working in a small start-up offers different experiences and growth opportunities compared to a role in a large, established corporation. Your preference here will really influence your job satisfaction and professional growth.

You could reflect on the importance of work-life balance in your life. Are you willing to work extended hours for a high-paced career trajectory, or do you prioritise flexibility and a more balanced lifestyle? This is crucial in ensuring that your new role aligns with your personal life and overall well-being.

Another aspect to think about is any opportunities for professional development a new role might offer. In today’s ever-changing job market, continuous learning and upskilling are key to maintaining employability. Look at whether potential roles offer learning opportunities, either through formal training, on-the-job learning, or exposure to new challenges.

Understand precisely what you are looking for or know that you need help defining it

Be honest with yourself about your current skills and the areas where you may need a bit of work to level up. This will help in finding roles that match your abilities and also identify areas for growth, hopefully boosting your attractiveness to potential employers. Don’t worry if you have little or limited knowledge of the job market or what the current benchmarks for your skills are, as a good recruitment consultant will uncover not only what you are interested in, but also what suits your skillsets and career goals.

5 tips for choosing the right recruitment agency

2. Specialist or Generalist Recruitment Agency?

Are you set on a specific sector, or are you exploring your options? If you are open to a new experience or currently considering a career change, generalist agencies should be your first port of call. However, if you are trained in a specialised industry, Specialist Agencies focus on specific industries or job functions, offering expertise and in-depth knowledge in particular sectors (such as IT!). These agencies have established networks within niche markets, which are invaluable when looking for opportunities in specialised fields.

For example, if you are seeking a role in a sector such as Information Technology, Healthcare, or Finance, a specialist agency will provide insights into industry-specific trends, salary benchmarks, and in-demand skills. They can also offer tailored advice on career progression and development within these sectors. On top of all that, their deep knowledge of their industry vertical allows them to accurately match your skills and experience with suitable roles, regularly including positions that may not be publicly advertised.

When deciding between the two, consider the stage of your career and your long-term goals (from above). If you are well-established in a particular field and looking to advance within that area, a specialist agency will serve your needs better. They will provide targeted opportunities and industry-specific guidance. On the other hand, if you are at a career crossroads, seeking to broaden your outlook, or unsure about the industry you want to pursue, a generalist agency could offer a broader perspective and a more appropriate range of opportunities.

Also, think about the level of support and guidance you expect from an agency. Specialist agencies will likely offer more personalised advice and mentorship in your field, while generalist agencies might provide a wider view of the job market and various career paths.

3. Leveraging Peer Recommendations

When looking for a recruitment agency, consider asking for recommendations from your professional network. Peers who have navigated the job market can offer valuable insights into their experiences with different agencies. They will be able to share the level of support and guidance they received, the quality of job matches, and the overall efficiency of the process. Such firsthand experiences will help you gauge an agency’s reputation and effectiveness.

This feedback can be key in identifying agencies that have a proven track record of supporting job seekers in your field. Be sure to ask specific questions about their experiences to get a clear picture of what to expect.

4. Evaluating Recruitment Agencies through Their Websites

A recruitment agency’s website can be a huge source of information and a reflection of their professionalism and vertical expertise. Take the time to examine the team’s background and experience, as this can give you an idea of their understanding of your industry and the type of roles they typically handle. The job board can offer insights into the kind of opportunities they frequently work on (though most often not a true reflection of what they are working on – something a conversation will quickly uncover).

Additionally, educational resources such as blogs or market insights indicate the agency’s commitment to keeping both themselves and their candidates informed about industry trends and best practices.

5. Follow the Recruitment Agency’s Social Media Activity

Find an agency that stays in touch with the latest developments in the job market, as well as having a reputation for success. As social media is the preferred medium of communication for many people, good recruitment agencies tend to post regular updates on their social channels to stay in touch with their network and keep them informed of sector-specific updates. While LinkedIn is the preferred channel of communication for many agencies, it is also worthwhile to check other channels for content that you may prefer to engage with (yes, even Tiktok!).

In today’s digital age, an agency’s social media presence can be a good indicator of its dynamism and relevance in the job market.


New Zealand is home to many recruitment agencies across a huge range of industries and specialisations. Being so spoilt for choice, many jobseekers find it difficult to take the first step and approach an agency, even though they require support. However, sometimes all it takes to find the right agency is to simply talk to one about what you need.

Sourced is a specialist, experienced and local agency that guides IT professionals in Christchurch and Auckland. If you are still unsure of which agency is the best fit for your needs, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us to find out more.

  Message us